Weaponizing Copyright and Non-Copyright Objectives – www.natlawreview.com

Weaponizing Copyright and Non-Copyright Objectives

From www.natlawreview.com
2021-09-28 17:53:08


Consider these two seemingly different scenarios.  In the first, a police officer, facing a provocateur recording him with a cell phone camera, pulls out his own phone and blasts a Taylor Swift song.  In the second, a home owner, after discovering to her horror that her Martha’s Vineyard residence was used as a set for pornographic videos, obtains a copyright registration for the home’s decorative accessories and files an infringement suit in federal court.  What do these two scenarios have in common?  Both the police officer and the home owner are allegedly “weaponizing” copyright, using copyright to achieve “non-copyright” objectives.  In both instances, a copyright for a work in the background has been seized upon as a vehicle to silence an opponent or to punish wrongdoing.

For those not steeped in copyright law, unpacking some of these issues begins with understanding the way the law treats “incidental” or “ambient” use of copyrighted works. Because a copyright attaches to original works of authorship immediately upon their creation in a tangible medium of expression, a copyright is relatively easy to obtain.  And anyone wielding a copyright has significant reach because anyone else—whether intentionally or not—who reproduces, publicly displays, distributes, or creates derivatives of the work potentially infringes the copyright.

So what about the police officer jamming to Taylor Swift?  Rather than weaponizing his own copyright, the officer is actually relying on Taylor Swift’s copyright and social media’s algorithms.  This BBC story analyzes this phenomenon in more detail, but in short, the officer is hoping that any attempt by the provocateur to upload a “gotcha” video of her encounter with the officer will be blocked by the platform’s algorithms designed to preclude copyrighted music from posting…

Read Full Article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Another Judge Stops Military Enforcement of Vaccine Mandate

Following a Texas Judge stopping the prosecution of soldiers for not getting vaccinated, another judge, this one in Florida, has also stopped the prosection of two soldiers that refused to get the vaccine for religious reasons. Military can’t discipline officers for refusing vaccine, Florida judge rules From www.tampabay.com 2022-02-07 18:36:52 Excerpt:    In a stinging […]

Read More

Arizona Bill Would Force Christians to Bake the LGBTQ Cake

A bipartisan effort appears to be going forward in Arizona that would force the metaphorical and literal Christian baker to bake the metaphorical and literal LGBTQ Cake.  The bill is being introduced and sponsored by a number of Arizona Representatives, including the Republican Speaker of the House. Lawmakers introduce Arizona LGBT anti-discrimination bill From www.thetelegraph.com […]

Read More

VA SCOTUS Rejects Pro-Mask Mandate Petition Against Youngkin

The VA Supreme Court rejected a petition to reverse the Youngkin order that public schools cannot mandate mask wearing for kids.  The petition was rejected on procedural grounds. Virginia Supreme Court dismisses mask mandate petition From abcnews.go.com 2022-02-07 20:25:44 Excerpt:   LEESBURG, Va. — The Supreme Court of Virginia on Monday rejected on procedural grounds […]

Read More